Holistic Squid RSS Holistic Squid Twitter Holistic Squid Facebook Holistic Squid Instagram Holistic Squid Google+

Do You Need High Vitamin Butter Oil to get Enough Vitamin K2?

Do You Need High Vitamin Butter Oil to get Enough Vitamin K2? - Holistic Squid What is Vitamin K2?

Vitamin K2 is a little known but extremely important fat-soluble vitamin. We classically think of Vitamin K for it’s role in blood clotting, however, this task is accomplished by vitamin K1, which is found in leafy green plants.

Vitamin K2, on the other hand, is primarily found in dairy and liver from animals raised on grassy, sunny pastures as well as fermented foods.  Vitamin K2 plays a key role in being distributed properly to bones and teeth and preventing calcium from being deposited into soft tissue such as blood vessels and kidneys. Vitamin K2 also aids in the synthesis of important fats involved in brain metabolism.

Which foods contain vitamin K2?

According to this article which sites a study in the Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemistry, the top 10 sources of Vitamin K2 are:

  1. Natto – 1103.4 mcg K2/100G  [see note below*]
  2. Goose Liver Paste – 369.0 mcg K2/100G [100g  = 3.53 ounces]
  3. Hard Cheeses – 76.3 mcg K2/100G
  4. Soft Cheeses – 56.5 mcg K2/100G
  5. Egg Yolk (Netherlands) - 32.1mcg K2/100G [approximately 6 yolks]
  6. Goose Leg – 31.0 mcg K2/100G
  7. Curd Cheeses -24.8 mcg K2/100G
  8. Egg Yolk (United States) -15.5 mcg K2/100G [approximately 6 yolks]
  9. Butter - 15.0 mcg K2/100G
  10. Chicken Liver - 14.1 mcg K2/100G

*A note about natto: I have read varying opinions about whether or not the type of K2 provided by natto (known as MK-7) and other fermented foods demonstrates the same properties as the K2 found in grass-fed dairy and meat (MK-4). Including natto in your diet is certainly not a bad idea as fermented foods are chock full of health benefits, however, if you rely on it as your sole source of K2, you may want to consider adding some animal-based sources and/or supplementing with high vitamin butter oil.

Some other sources site that fish eggs are also quite high in K2. Certain cheeses such as gouda do not need to be made from grass fed milk, since the culturing process produces vitamin K2 in the finished cheese.  But for nearly every other K2 rich food, the pasture-raised component is essential. (Click here to learn where you can buy cheese cultures to make your own vitamin K2-rich gouda).

Notice that butter is lower on this list, and 100g of butter is about 7 tablespoons, providing only 15 mcg of K2. An official recommended daily allowance for vitamin K2 has not been established at this time, but some experts (including Mercola and Kresser) recommend aiming for 100 mcg/day. To get 100mcg of K2 from butter alone, according to this list you would need nearly 6 sticks of butter per day.  Now, I eat A LOT of butter, but six sticks daily is even too much for me.  What we don’t know here is whether or not this butter was from grass-fed cows, which would make all the difference since butter from conventional butter doesn’t contain much vitamin K2 at all.

You can also see that the egg yolk for the Netherlands contained DOUBLE the vitamin K2 compared to the egg from the United States. Hmm. I wonder if that U.S. egg was from a conventional source and the Dutch egg from a pastured source?

In summary, we can see that the liver and dark meat from fowl, hard and soft cheese and egg yolk come out on top when it comes to vitamin K2 content. Don’t you think it would be interesting to see a similar study done of grass fed vs. conventional sources – specifically regarding butter?. Who’s got a lab and some free time?

What is high vitamin butter oil?

High vitamin butter oil (HVBO) is a concentrated supplement made by centrifuging the oil of grass fed butter to concentrate the vitamin density.  In his book, Nutrition and Physical Degeneration-, Weston Price discussed the use of HVBO from fall and spring cows on pasture to maximize the health benefits of  fermented cod liver oil (FCLO) – Essentially, the fat-soluble vitamins A and D from the FCLO seem to work synergistically with vitamin K2 (which Price referred to as ‘Activator X’) from HVBO.

Because HVBO is technically classified as a food not a supplement, the precise content of vitamin K2 is not included on the label.  It has been suggested on various sources online, however, that the HVBO is estimated at eight times more potent than regular butter, putting HBVO near the top of our list above. HVBO is also casein and lactose-free – safe for most individuals with sensitivity to dairy.

How much High Vitamin Butter Oil do you need?

If you are supplementing with HVBO, here’s some tips on dosage:

According to Ramiel Nigel, author of Cure Tooth Decay-, for severe cavities or severe tooth pain or infection, you want 3/4 teaspoon of fermented cod liver oil and 3/4 teaspoon of butter oil daily.  This is equivalent to 10 capsules of the FCLO / HVBO blend or 7 capsules of each individually. For maintenance dosages, about half the amounts listed for adults. You can read more about dosage of FCLO in this post.

It’s likely that the similar dosage recommendations would be ideal for treatment or prevention of other disease or imbalances as well. While pregnancy is certainly not a disease, it is quite demanding on the body, so women who are trying to conceive, pregnant, or nursing should aim for the higher dosage range. At the time of this writing, there is no known toxicity if vitamin K2 is taken in large dosages.

Ultimately, each individual is different and may require different amount of vitamin K2. Listen to your body, and when in doubt, be sure to consult with a qualified health practitioner.

Is High Vitamin Butter Oil worth the cost? 

At $60 for a 240 ml bottle or $45 for 120 capsules, HVBO may seem out of your budget.  But HVBO packs a punch when it comes to vitamin K2. At a maintenance dose of 4 capsules per day, a single bottle of capsules (my preferred delivery method) will last two months. Compared to the cost of the equivalent vitamin K2 foods, HVBO may start to look like a bargain.

This is the high vitamin butter oil that I take.

10 reasons you may want to supplement with high vitamin butter oil:

  1. You do not have access to butter, liver, eggs and meat from grass fed animals.
  2. You choose not to eat the grass fed animal foods above liberally or at all.
  3. You are trying to conceive.
  4. You are pregnant or nursing.
  5. You are a growing child.
  6. You are a hormonal adolescent or woman experiencing premenstrual syndrome.
  7. You are nearing or going through menopause.
  8. You are experiencing dental decay, tooth sensitivity, or gum disease or are seeking to prevent dental issues.
  9. You suffer from or are predisposed to heart disease, osteoporosis (or other bone conditions), rheumatoid arthritis, diabetesalzheimer’s disease, or certain types of cancer.
  10. The cost of HVBO is not prohibitive to you.

This is just a partial list of who may benefit from HVBO.  You can read more about the content and benefits of HVBO here.

The good news for individuals with decent health and/or a tight budget, is that eating ample foods on a regular basis that are high in vitamin K2 will usually suffice.

Rather than depending on charts and guesses for vitamin content in food, my personal preference is to supplement with some HVBO, eat vitamin K2 foods in abundance, and then pay attention to my body’s request for more (or less). I take more FCLO and HVBO if my teeth are feeling sensitive or my hormones seem out of balance. If I’m feeling under the weather, I’ll take an extra fistful of FCLO caps.  How do you decide how much FCLO and HVBO to take?

Get high vitamin butter oil here.

 

References:

Fallon, Sally, and Mary Enig. “Cod Liver Oil Basics and Recommendations.” http://www.westonaprice.org/cod-liver-oil/cod-liver-oil-basics
Kresser, Chris. “9 Steps to Perfect Health” http://chriskresser.com/9-steps-to-perfect-health-4-supplement-wisely
Masterjohn, Chris. “On the Trail of the Elusive X-Factor: A Sixty-Two-Year-Old Mystery Finally Solved.” http://www.westonaprice.org/fat-soluble-activators/x-factor-is-vitamin-k2
Masterjohn, Chris. “Vegetarianism and Nutrient Deficiencies.” http://www.westonaprice.org/vegetarianism-and-plant-foods/vegetarianism-and-nutrient-deficiencies
McGrunther, Jenny and Dr. Kate Rheaume-Bleue. “Vitamin K2: A Reader Question & Answer.” http://nourishedkitchen.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/K2.pdf
Mercola MD, Joe. “10 Important Facts About Vitamin K That You Need to Know.” http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2004/03/24/vitamin-k-part-two.aspx
Nagel, Ramiel. http://www.curetoothdecay.com/support-with-tooth-decay/support-green-pastures-capsule.htm
Sisson, Mark. “Dear Mark: Vitamin K2.” http://www.marksdailyapple.com/vitamin-k2/#ixzz1mhuvhxnu

Disclaimer

PAID ENDORSEMENT DISCLOSURE: I may receive monetary compensation or other types of remuneration for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial and/or link to any products or services from this blog. These small earnings make it possible for me to continue writing this blog for you. That said, I will never endorse any product or service that I cannot fully support.

Like What You've Read?
Subscribe to Holistic Squid by email and never miss a post!

Related posts that may interest you

Comments

  1. Heather Bain Brandt via Facebook says:

    I’ll be interested to read your article. I’m dairy intolerant (so far doing okay on ghee after over a year without dairy) & concerned about how to get enough K2 with dairy intolerance (hoping GAPS has helped with my prob).

  2. lara gunther says:

    Hi
    There

    I am confused about the amount of cod liver oil Rami recommends for extreme cases. I thought adults as a daily dose were supposed to take 10000 of vit A which is alot more than 3/4 teaspoon . This is the amount sally fallon talks about on the weston price website.

    Love to know your thoughts

    Lara

  3. [...] liquid whey, good quality cream, lactose, bifidobacterium infantis, fermented cod liver oil, high-vitamin butter oil, expeller-expressed sunflower oil, extra virgin olive oil, coconut oil, nutritional yeast [...]

  4. Kathy says:

    Just to let your readers know that I found another source to buy High Vitamin Butter oil at very reasonable price. I have used GP product for an year and the taste of NutraPro butter oil is much better than GP product.
    http://nutraprointl.com

  5. Marie M. Bennett says:

    Vitamin K2 plays a key role in being distributed properly to bones and teeth and preventing calcium from being deposited into soft tissue such as blood vessels and kidneys.”

    So do you have other alternative food list aside from the 10 listed above? I really want to learn more about vitamin k so I want to know which foods are rich in vit k.

  6. James A. Randle says:

    Thanks for this good information. I’m really interested in learning vitamins and their benefits specially this vitamin k2. I usually buy some of my vitamins here in http://worldofsupplements.com/, they are actually good!

  7. [...] I could tell you all about benefits of cod liver oil for infertility, pregnancy, flu prevention, and so much more. I also can tell you tricks for taking it, and how much you need, plus everything you ever wanted to know about high vitamin butter oil. [...]

  8. [...] X factor, now known to be Vitamin K2 (Nourishing Traditions 618). It’s estimated that HVBO is eight times more potent than regular dietary butter. Dr. Price believed that cod liver oil was more effective when given with high-vitamin butter or [...]

  9. Abi says:

    Isn’t HVBO the same as ghee as long as you make the ghee from organic, grass-fed butter?

    • Emily says:

      Hi Abi – My understanding is that high vitamin butter oil (HVBO) is a concentrated supplement made by centrifuging the oil of grass fed butter to concentrate the vitamin density.

  10. Kirista says:

    So I have a questions I take FCLO but was only taking 2 capsules because thats what it says on the bottle to take the recommended 10 capsules would mean Id be spending over 100.00 a month on FCLO not to mention buying HVBO and buying all that for my husband and son along with everything else eating healthy entitles. Is taking a little bit of FCLO worth it or is it all or nothing? We eat liver 2 times a week as well and eat very healthy lots of raw grassfed butter. Also I put the FCLO in my sons diaper at bed time because thats what it said to do the nourished baby book, at what age do you start giving it to them? He is 14 months I tried today but he was so disgusted by it and spit it out of his mouth.

  11. Summer says:

    I have read a lot of info on FCLO and HVBO and this post doesnt explain much at all. A bit disapointed.

  12. Sara says:

    I give my 9 mo daugheter a 1/2 tsp on non flavored FCLO daily. Any thought on when to start the HVBO?

    • Emily says:

      Hi Sara – If she’s getting plenty of grass fed dairy, I wouldn’t worry about it. I would save the HVBO for adults and kids that don’t get grass fed dairy or have health concerns that require extra Vitamin K2.

  13. Sandra says:

    I am curious on your thoughts about Green Pastures product. I currently buy the combo FCLO/butter oil, but I was told that the dosing is not high enough for the butter oil.

    Do you recommend buying two separate bottles?

  14. So what is the K2 mcg level in HVBO? Did I miss it in the article? It’s hard to compare its worth compared to the food sources without that information. I saw their recommended dosage but that’s the same thing.

  15. [...] K Foods Coumadin Users Should Watch For | INR Tracker and Vitamin K2: The Missing Nutrient and Do You Need High Butter Vitamin Oil to get Vitamin K2? – Holistic Squid 2. You don't need the ammounts of vit k he suggests bc theres almost no way on god's or jah's or [...]

  16. John says:

    There is a good article on K2 over on this site:

    http://www.omegavia.com/vitamin-k2-part-2/#comment-25953

    I also wonder how the approximate dose of K2 in 3/4 of a tsp of HVBO compares to the 200mcg of K2 in the supplement that is recommended in that article. And I assume that MK-4 is what is found in HVBO, not MK-7? What dose should we shoot for of each?

  17. Tiberius says:

    The quantities of vitamin K2 in foods, quoted in this article, are significantly different than what is reported in a study published in The Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry.

    http://www.ars.usda.gov/SP2UserFiles/Place/12354500/Articles/JAFC54_463-467.pdf

  18. [...] #7 – Eat natto (fermented soy beans) or take a Vitamin K2 supplement. Ideally you will get vitamin K2 from dairy from grass fed cows. This little known nutrient is important for calcium distribution – an essential function when you’re asking your body to grow a small human’s teeth and bone. Read more about vitamin K2 here. [...]

  19. Nyx says:

    Hi, thanks for the article, especially for reprinting the list with the numbers. I am so disorganized that about once a month I find myself turning to Google to look for these numbers again! So it’s nice that you put them here for easy reference. I have been doing the gouda vs. hvbo math, and I’m thinking that about 3 oz. per day of gouda might be about equivalent, but I’m wondering if I have really done that correctly. if that’s true though, then for cost comparison purposes I’m wondering if you’re not better off OVERALL just eating the cheese, because instead of getting just the fat soluble vitamins, you’ll also get the protein, other fats (if it is 8x more concentrated then ghee, then I assume that means that somehow the centrifuge process actually separates some fats from others), water-soluble vitamins? if this is concentrated from the fat, then I have to wonder what happens to the b12, which seems to be abundant in the gouda!, minerals and extra calories! So … if you don’t have an allergy or sensitivity to dairy proteins, then why would you be better off to take the butter oil capsules than to just eat 3 oz of gouda? or is there something I’m overlooking? I’d love to have someone else’s thoughts.

  20. […] liquid whey, good quality cream, lactose, bifidobacterium infantis, fermented cod liver oil, high-vitamin butter oil, expeller-expressed sunflower oil, extra virgin olive oil, coconut oil, nutritional yeast […]

  21. […] dairy do great with ghee which is lucky since it’s rich in fat soluble vitamins including vitamin K2 which is essential for healthy bones and […]

Speak Your Mind

*

allcladpopup